Portsmouth

Division 2 2002/2003 Analysis

Summary

Final Table

Average Grade of Teams

Chichester B

Cosham B

Emsworth B

Fareham A

Gosport C

Portsmouth

Summary

Emsworth B and Chichester B both stood head and shoulders above the other teams in Division Two and were vying for the top position all during the season. In the end Emsworth B were successful, obtaining one more match point than Chichester B, both teams only lost the one match, to each other. 

This leaves the same issue as last season, with Emsworth B reluctant to have two teams in Division One, as key players for both teams currently play for both teams. It will be interesting to see how this develops, as I feel having only five teams in Division One is not an ideal situation.

A number of excellent performances were seen, in particular A.H.McDougall, Andrew Smith, S.Symons and Ray Williams. 

Final Table

Team

P

W

D

L

GS

Pts

Emsworth B

10

8

1

1

38

17

Chichester B

10

7

2

1

41

16

Cosham B

10

4

1

5

31½

9

Gosport C

10

2

3

5

26

7

Portsmouth

10

3

1

6

21½

7

Fareham A 10 1 2 7 21½ 4

 

Average Grade of Teams

Team

Average Grade

Chichester B

133.8

Emsworth B

130.2

Cosham B

123.7

Gosport C

113.1

Fareham A

111.7

Portsmouth

102.7

 

On paper Chichester B had the strongest team, but Emsworth B were not far behind. This is slightly misleading, as there were sometimes huge differences in grades between the top and bottom boards. A case in point is Portsmouth who in a couple of games had a difference in grade of over 100 points between board one and board five.

 

Chichester B

Name

Grade

Played

Won

Drawn

Lost

Points 

%

Grading Perf

P.A.Rayment

121

10

6

3

1

7.5

75.0

127.9

A.H.McDougall

153

7

5

1

1

5.5

78.6

174.3

M.Plumb

118

7

5

1

1

5.5

78.6

122.4

R.T.F.Williams

150

4

3

1

0

3.5

87.5

167.5

K.Davies

138

8

2

3

3

3.5

43.8

108.1

A.Likhoded

112

3

3

0

0

3.0

100.0

139.0

S.J.Smith

147

4

3

0

1

3.0

75.0

156.5

I.A.Richardson

119

5

1

2

2

2.0

40.0

92.8

C.Squires

u

2

1

1

0

1.5

75.0

133.5

A.McCumiskey

184

1

1

0

0

1.0

100.0

201.0

P.Wake

95

1

1

0

0

1.0

100.0

105.0

W.Partridge

145

4

1

0

3

1.0

25.0

116.5

Total

 

56

32

12

12

38.0

67.9

 

Chichester B used twelve players in their B team, with only one person playing in all games. Therefore it was rare for the same team to be playing in more than one match and they fell just short of winning the league. Like Division Two champions Emsworth B a number of payers who played in the B team, also played for the A team. The difference though is that with fifteen players playing for either the A or B team, on paper it would not be an issue if Chichester B were promoted to Division One. The teams would not be that weak either, as nine of the players who played for the A or B teams were graded 138 or above. This compares with Emsworth's twelve players who played for the A and B team, of which only five were graded above 138.

Whereas in Division One A.H.McDougall had a torrid time, he had an excellent season in Division Two, with five wins, one draw and only one defeat. This included wins against Joe Coburn, Dave Elliott and Sherif Gonem. Other players who played well were P.A.Rayment, Ray Williams and A.Likhoded. 

Top of page

Cosham B

Name

Grade

Played

Won

Drawn

Lost

Points 

%

Grading Perf

A.D.Smith

139

7

4

3

0

5.5

78.6

168.6

S.Dean

137

9

5

1

3

5.5

61.1

145.6

P.Dallas

114

8

4

2

2

5.0

62.5

124.9

R.E.Treloar

108

9

3

2

4

4.0

44.1

98.9

S.D.LeFevre

128

4

2

2

0

3.0

75.0

124.8

T.W.Woodroofe

104

7

2

0

5

2.0

28.6

69.6

W.D.Muir

u

2

1

1

0

1.5

75.0

166.5

D.Gibson

149

1

1

0

0

1.0

100.0

237.0

K.Eyles

u

6

1

0

5

1.0

16.7

77.6

S.Gonem

143

3

0

0

3

0.0

0.0

103.0

A.F.Carter

153

1

0

0

1

0.0

0.0

91.0

Total

 

57

23

11

23

28.50

50.0

 

Cosham had six players who played the majority of games, with five players filling in as reserves. Although the team was not too successful against the top two teams on the whole they were too strong for the other teams in the division and deserved their third place.

Andrew Smith had by far the best result of a Cosham player, remaining unbeaten and his wins included ones against Steve Smith and Joe Coburn. Although D.Gibson only played one game, this was a win against A.Fysh-Foskett, which explains the 237 performance.

Top of page

Emsworth B

Name

Grade

Played

Won

Drawn

Lost

Points 

%

Grading Perf

I.Cary

151

10

6

2

2

7.0

70.0

153.1

R.H.Storr-best

126

9

5

2

2

6.0

66.7

124.1

N.Harrison

109

9

5

2

2

6.0

66.7

121.3

S.Symons

114

5

4

1

0

4.5

90.0

141.6

M.Krawczuk

165

6

2

4

0

4.0

66.7

168.0

M.G.Buckley

147

7

1

5

1

3.5

50.0

142.7

J.Mach

123

5

2

2

1

3.0

60.0

126.0

D.Shotton

101

3

1

1

1

1.5

50.0

105.0

V.Agius

100

2

1

0

1

1.0

50.0

110.5

Ray Smith

116

3

0

1

2

0.5

16.7

68.3

Total

 

59

27

20

12

37.0

62.7

 

Another fine season saw Emsworth B retain their Division Two title, finishing one point above Chichester B. With the exception on one player, all of the Emsworth B players scored 50% or more in the season, with five players scoring more than 65%. This consistency certainly helped Emsworth B win the division. 

Looking at the individual scores, the majority of players scored their expected results, which seemed to be enough to win the league. S.Symons and Neil Harrison were the exception, with S.Symons in particular performing in excess of his grade with his four wins and a draw from five games. Neil's performance would have been even higher if he had beaten Tony Elbourn in a game in which there was some controversy and Neil ended up losing.

I suppose the only outstanding point now, is if Emsworth B are going to go up to Division One, or if they are going to ask to stay in Division Two again. I am sure this will be sorted out at the Portsmouth AGM.

Top of page

Fareham A

Name

Grade

Played

Won

Drawn

Lost

Points 

%

Grading Perf

D.Elliott

141

9

4

3

2

5.5

61.1

148.1

J.A.Coburn

146

9

3

1

5

3.5

38.9

130.6

P.Waller

103

6

1

3

2

2.5

41.7

99.7

M.Mitchell

93

8

1

3

4

2.5

31.3

107.5

J.R.Craig

97

6

2

0

4

2.0

33.3

90.3

B.Massey

89

2

1

1

0

1.5

75.0

117.0

M.Springthorpe

81

3

1

0

2

1.0

33.3

77.7

S.Eva

91

3

1

0

2

1.0

33.3

73.0

L.Springthorpe

95

5

0

1

4

0.5

10.0

71.4

S.Jones

u

1

0

0

1

0.0

0.0

64.0

G.Humby

u

1

0

0

1

0.0

0.0

63.0

P.Walters

u

1

0

0

1

0.0

0.0

54.0